i know sams gonna be 6 next year having IL saying there will be no new signings, but what would people think about smith cumng back if he had the chance

i'd have smith 6 and sam 7

yeah but what about lulu, think we might be betta with smith 6, lulu 7 and tomkins on bench

Is this a possible rumour? thought he was looking good before he got injured and him and sam seemed to play well together.

i'd have tommy at 9, bo11ocks to Riddell

IL said at the FF that Smith hadn't gone home.
Not sure that he may be having his op here and then going back.

No thanks. Timmy smiths days at wigan are well and truely over

Smith is by far a better playmaker then Sam

But he cant tackle and has no pace. I have never seen a bigger turnstyle in defence, some of his efforts at tackling were shockingly bad.

I'm the opposite TD.

I'd love Tim to come and have another season.

He's been improving all year, and on top of that, we *need* another 6 or7 as after Tomkins & Lulu, we're down to an untried kid.

exactly

All Smith can do is pass. He's a robot.